Are Your Stairs Safe?
22/09/2008 - The Australian Building Codes Board recently commissioned the Monash University Accident Research Centre (MUARC) to study the incidence of slips, trips and falls and their relationship to the design and construction of buildings. The study is now complete and the findings show the problem is significant.In Australia each year there are over 500 fatal falls and over 110,000 hospital admissions.
These resulting from falls in buildings and the numbers are increasing as the population ages and also shows the annual cost is around $1.3 billion per annum.
Falls on stairs account for over 60% of slip, trip and fall deaths in buildings and can result due to a number of complex interacting factors. Despite this, there are minimal safe design and construction principles within building regulations; however the following environmental factors when evaluating safe egress on stairways include:
• The visibility of the stairway
• Slip resistance of stair treads
• Provision of suitable handrails
• Dimensional geometry of stairs
The visibility of the stairway is critical to ensure that a person can prepare to coordinate their gait during stair ascent and decent. For people with ‘normal’ vision this relies on visual clues such as handrails, depth perception in good lighting conditions and high visibility of step nosings. Poor delineation of the step edge may confuse people negotiating the stairs, particularly in poor lighting conditions thus increasing the risk of a miss step.
Best practice is to set slip resistive strips with a luminance contrast greater than 30% to the very edge of the stairs. The width of the strips should be between 50-75mm, this assists persons to negotiate the stairs by clearly delineating the step edge, thus minimising the risk of a miss-step. This is increasingly important when people’s eyes require time to adapt to lower lighting conditions.
To highlight best practice, these stair features are required for disability access requirements within AS 1428.1, Design for Access and Mobility; Part 1: General requirements for access – Buildings.
The slip resistance in terms of the Required Coefficient of Friction (RCOF) during moderately paced stair descent is comparable to that found during over ground walking . It has been found that the RCOF of stair descent during weight acceptance is approximately 0.26 . Thus in the absence of contaminants on the stair tread, frictional factors play a minor role in stair safety during descent for internal stairs that are maintained in a clean and dry condition, unless subjects wear poor footwear, resulting in low coefficients of friction.
For external stairs and transitional areas in entrances, the slip resistance can be a significant factor and stair treads should achieve Pendulum Class W for public areas where water contamination is likely, when tested to AS/NZS 4586, Slip Resistance Classification of Pedestrian Surface Materials. Any slip resistant strips must be installed to the edge of the nosing as when a person descends a flight of stairs, with an approximate going of 250mm, the foot tends to make contact within 5 mm from the step edge.
The provision of handrails provides a visual clue that there are steps present to negotiate. Handrails reduce the risk of a miss-step by increasing postural stability and assisting as a fall restraint. The Building Code of Australia (BCA) provides limited prescriptive requirements on handrails design. Besides the handrail height above the step best practice is for the railing is to be semicircular, with not less than 30 mm or more than 50 mm diameter for not less than 270º around the upper surface that does not tend to break a handhold. This handrail arrangement provides a power grip, which encompasses the majority of the handrail assisting fall arrest, rather than a relying on a pinch grip.
The dimensional geometry of stairs should establish a suitable gait pattern that is consistent throughout the flight of stairs. For commercial premises the BCA requirements are that dimensions risers be between 115 – 190 mm and goings between 250 – 355 mm. An attempt should be made for goings to be greater than 300 mm as the risk of over stepping the edge of the stair is significantly reduced. The going to riser ratio (2R + G) within the range of 550 – 700 assists to promote a suitable gait pattern.
Dimensional inconsistency of stair going and risers can have a tremendous impact on a persons gait and balance, and are generally not visually obvious. Stairs with an irregularity as little as 6 mm between adjacent rise and runs can disrupt foot movements enough to cause a fall. A person has an expectation of a certain distance at which to place their foot at each step. If their expectation is not met, a fall can result from a misstep. This most often occurs when the going dimensions are reduced significantly near the bottom of stairs when the pedestrian has built a degree of confidence of where the next step will be to ensure proper foot placement.
Global Safe Technologies Safe Grip Stair Nosing can signficaintly reduce the risk of slip and miss steps to stairs. The enviromentally friendly polymer coating system is applied along the edge of the nosing between 50-75 mmm in width and between 1.5mm to 2mm thickness. The Safe Grip Stair Nosing is stable underfoot and does not pose a tripping hazard. The colour range has undergone independent slip resistance and luminance contrast testing, resulting the nosing provided will be fully compliant with the relevant slip resistance handbook HB197:1999 and also with AS 1428.1 – 2001 requirements.
On request Safe Environments Pty Ltd can provide luminance reflectance and contrast testing, risk assessments and certification of the stair installations.
The product also has the additional advantage of providing protection of the actual nosing as well as being “applied” onto the surface, it has no issues with loose screws and with a trip hazard or pests harbouring udnerneath.
For further information about stair safety risk assessments including luminance contrast requirements, slip resistance testing please contact Carl Strautins from Safe Environments Pty Ltd on 02 9889 3002 or visit http://www.SafeEnvironments.com.au and Global Safe Technologies Australia’s non slip solutions range of products call us on 1300 668 620 or visit our website www.globalsafe.com.au/index.php#solution