Industry Search Australia Trusted by 600,000+ buyers

Manufacturers express "deep concern" about skills shortages

By: Peter Field
16 May, 2011

Australian Industry Group members say lack of trained staff will present a "high risk factor" in the next five years.

A shortage of skilled workers is becoming a major problem for Australian manufacturers and is a major reason why productivity improvements are slowing, Lee-Anne Fisher of the Australian Industry Group (Ai Group), claims.

Fisher, the AiG’s Manager for Policy and Projects Education and Training, says that among the 60,000 businesses that the Ai Group represents – the majority of which are in manufacturing - concern about skills shortages is increasing.

Fisher was speaking at the recent Western Sydney Manufacturing Leaders Forum, held at the Sydney Olympic Centre. The Forum is an event that supports National Manufacturing Week (NMW). NMW will take place in Melbourne at the end of May and is organised by Reed Exhibitions

"Many company bosses say, that in as little as five years, the lack of skilled people will be a factor in preventing further productivity gains," Fisher told the audience of Sydney-based industry executives.

In a list of factors that manufacturers gave as reasons for not employing job applicants, Fisher noted that the top four related to lack of skills. According to manufacturers, the three commonest reasons for turning applicants away were: a lack of specialised skills (60 percent of employers); a lack of general skills (54 percent), and a lack of job-specific training (32 percent).

And skills shortages are more extreme in some trades than others. According to Fisher, companies were unable to fill nearly 60 percent of vacancies for fitters and machinists, whereas machine operators were a lot easier to come by with only around 7 percent of vacancies left open.

Companies believe that Federal and State Governments should be more actively involved in resolving the problem, but don’t necessarily consider skilled immigration to be the answer. 37.8 percent of those companies interviewed by Ai Group said they would prefer to "upskill the current staff", while only 9.6 percent considered overseas recruitment to be the answer to the skills shortages.

Notably, 12.6 percent of bosses said they would limit production to resolve the skills shortage while 31.2 percent considered overseas contracting was the answer.

However, Fisher said the solution could be much closer to home if only companies: "maximised the potential of their existing workforce for competitive advantage."

"Existing staff often have skills that are under utilised," she explained.

"Worse still, the higher the level of the skill, the more under utilised it is."

She noted that the Ai Group’s work with SMEs to help create "High Performance Workplaces" (HPW) has helped a select group of companies to make the most of existing talent in their organisations.

"HPW is not a new idea, but it’s time is coming," she said.

"The Ai Group is giving it the attention it deserves right now.

"Adopting HPW requires management leadership, participatory decision making, team-based work systems, workforce skill development and knowledge sharing. This will lead to productivity and profitability gains, low employee turnover and increased innovation.

"But it’s not easy," Fisher concluded.

"I’ve seen many examples of companies starting an HPW initiative but then stopping the program due to worker concerns, cost and management lacking in the skills to see it through."

Have your say...

We welcome thoughtful comments from readers
Reload characters
Type the characters you see in this box. This helps us prevent automated programs from sending spam.
Leon | Tuesday, June 7, 2011, 10:43 AM
Skills Shortage??? I am a licensed electrician and have an Adv Dip Engineering(Electrical)and Ass Dip Eng (Electronics)with experience with PLC's, VSD's SCADA systems and general maintenance. I have a industrial background. I have struggled to get work where i can apply my full range of skills. Mostly i work as a special class electrician, even when i try to apply my skills at the level i am trained to (with out asking for a pay rise) get told that we are not paying you for that. Most employers don't have enough work to keep me employed full time at the higher level which is why i am now contracting (I have been a contractor for 8 years now)but even that is difficult as they either don't under or don't want to understand what the paraprofessional trade people can offer. Most employers see it as black or white you are either a trades person or an engineer. I have tried numerous ways to promote and explain the advantages of the paraprofessional. But have pretty much given up. It is easier to tell everyone you are an electrician. They get that, but then i get told we have plenty of electricians. I don't think manufacturing companies are serious about the skills shortage. It is easier to wire houses at least every one seems to understand that.
Phil | Tuesday, June 21, 2011, 4:02 PM
There is no skills shortage that I can see. The problem is related to blinkered management and hiring practices - there is no recognition of transferrable experience and skills and work maturity. If you dont have experience specifically on device x and you're not under 30, try applying for a job as an electrician in'd be lucky to get an acknowledgment.